This Just In: For Microsoft Skype, the “Sky” is limited!

Sky-TV-Company-and-Skype-Sky-television-vs-Skype-Video-Chat-Service-Sky-TV-Logo-and-TV-Service-575261-590x250

By Ritvik M. Kulkarni 

In a decade-old trademark tussle between Microsoft and BSkyB, the latter has prevailed over the use of the word SKY in the market. Owned by Rupert Murdoch, BSkyB is a British television broadcasting company which procured trademark registrations its brand-name “Sky” long before Microsoft came up with its online communications service named “Skype”.

In the present dispute, the General Court of the European Union has accepted Sky’s argument that the word Microsoft’s usage of the word Skype is likely to confuse its users into believing that the latter is a service connected to services provided by Sky.  It has further held that due to such likelihood of confusion, Microsoft will be restrained obtaining a trademark registration for its “Skype” as well as its cloud-shaped logo in the European Union.

In the words of the Court, “Conceptually, the figurative element conveys no concept, except perhaps that of a cloud.”

“[That] would further increase the likelihood of the element ‘Sky’ being recognized within the word element ‘Skype’, for clouds are to be found ‘in the sky’ and thus may readily be associated with the word ‘sky’.

Implications

The immediate effect of this ruling is that Microsoft will be left in a vulnerable position in relation to the usage of the word “Skype” by third parties as the word can never be registered in the EU. However, the catch in this is that Microsoft may still be able to protect the mark and prevent others from riding on its reputation by employing the common law remedy of “passing-off”; but enforcement of this common law right can be very tedious and expensive as Microsoft will have to prove extensive usage, market-wide reputation and the element of passing-off. A registration on the other hand is itself enough proof that a particular is the private property of the registered TM owner.

Most importantly, even though presently BSkyB has not asked Microsoft to change the name for its (Skype) service, BSkyB may well be justified in approaching Microsoft to enter into a licensing agreement with the former to use the word SKY in the latter’s product/service.  This will put Microsoft into an extremely precarious position unless it secures an order in its favor at the appellate stage.

Opinion

In my opinion, it was wrong of the OHIM to grant a trademark for the word SKY in the first place, as the said word is a generic word and would create an unjust monopoly in the applicant for the usage of that word. Tomorrow if another company introduces a telephone service named Sky-High, BSkyB may well come after it and sue for trademark infringement. More specifically, a word like SKY becomes very important when it comes to certain products/services like cloud computing and aviation; where the word becomes almost descriptive of the product/service offered.

What do you think?

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “This Just In: For Microsoft Skype, the “Sky” is limited!

  1. Skype had been facing trademark problems since its creation in 2003 when BSkyB objected. Microsoft entered the game only in 2011 when it acquired Skype.
    BSkyB has not filed a suit against Microsoft once, but twice. It had also filed another complaint against Microsoft which led to the company’s online storage service Skydrive being renamed OneDrive.

    The case brings an interesting question to mind: If the word “Sky” is too generic to be trademarked, can we say the same about “Apple”?!

    Like

    1. You are right on both accounts Mr. Talwar. As far as the word Apple per se is concerned, it doesn’t seem to me like a generic word in relation to the services offered by Apple Inc. However, the word Sky, in my opinion, can be slightly descriptive as the services offered in that aspect is cloud computing and other ancillary services.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s